Skip to content
Phone: 541.338.9488 Contact Us 325 West 13th Avenue • Eugene, OR 97401

Architectural Designer vs Engineer in Oregon: Why Designer Plans Get Rejected

Designer plans get rejected at permit review because designers aren’t licensed design professionals, so they can’t stamp plans, and building departments require a stamp from a licensed architect or engineer for work that needs engineering. That’s the core of the architectural designer vs engineer question in Oregon, and it’s the most common costly mistake we see homeowners and contractors make.

We’re Johnson Broderick Engineering, consulting structural and civil engineers in Eugene. We get this call often: “I have a set of plans a designer drew up for me. I just need them engineered.” Here’s what’s usually going on, and how to avoid it.

Oakleigh Meadows co-housing structural engineering project, Eugene, Oregon — photo 2

What's the difference between a designer and an engineer?

A licensed engineer or architect is a registered design professional who can stamp plans. A designer isn’t licensed as a design professional, and has no authority to stamp the plans that building departments and building officials require.

Many designers are good at what they do: layout, look, how a space will feel. The issue isn’t talent. It’s licensing, and what the permit process requires.

Isn't an "architectural designer" an architect?

No. Many designers call themselves “architectural designers.” Honestly, that title can be misleading, because it sounds like “architect.” An architect is licensed; an architectural designer is not. If you’re not sure which you’re hiring, ask whether they’re licensed and whether they can stamp your plans.

What happens at permit review?

Unstamped plans for work that needs engineering get kicked out of review. The owner or contractor then calls an engineer, expecting to have the drawings “engineered” as they are.

When we review those plans, in many cases the design isn’t in compliance with code requirements. The structure has to be re-engineered from the beginning.

Why can't an engineer just stamp the designer's plans?

Because Oregon law doesn’t allow us to stamp plans prepared by someone else. A stamp means we prepared and stand behind the design. We can’t put it on drawings we didn’t produce, so the documents have to be prepared by us.

What does that cost the owner?

Usually, the cost of the designer’s plans. At that point the owner has paid for a set of drawings that, for permit purposes, is of little value, because the design has to be redone. That’s paying twice for one set of plans, plus the time lost to a rejected permit application.

Is it really cheaper to start with an engineer?

Yes, in most cases. It may seem counterintuitive, since a designer can look like the less expensive option. But having your plans prepared by a licensed design professional from the start avoids paying for drawings that need to be redesigned, and avoids a round of rejection at permit review. Our permit sets are generally well received by building departments with minimal questions, which saves time and frustration too.

How can I check before I hire someone?

Ask three questions before you pay for plans:

  • Are you licensed as an architect or engineer in Oregon? If not, they can’t stamp your plans.
  • Can you stamp these plans for permit? A licensed professional can answer yes or no immediately.
  • Will this project need engineering? If it involves structural changes, the answer is usually yes, and the person preparing the plans needs to be able to provide it.

If the answers leave you unsure, call us before you commit. We’ll tell you plainly what your project needs.

Why does starting with the engineer help?

Because the process goes more smoothly, and costs less, when the engineer is involved from the beginning and coordinates with you along the way. Engineering works best as a two-way conversation, not as a stamp bought at the end. Decisions made early, while the design is still flexible, avoid redesign later.

What if I already have designer plans?

Call us anyway. Your drawings still tell us what you want: the layout, the look, the goals. That’s useful starting information, even though we’ll prepare our own permit documents. We’ll look at what you have, tell you plainly where things stand, and give you a scope and deposit estimate for the engineering.

Do I even need an engineer for my project?

Not every project does. If yours involves load-bearing walls, added loads, retaining walls over 4 feet, involved remodels, or anything custom or unusual, it likely does. See do I need a structural engineer in Oregon?

Common questions

Can a contractor build from designer plans without a permit?

Building without a permit is the other common mistake we see, and it often ends with a letter from the city or county. If that’s already happened, read got a county letter about unpermitted construction?

How much will engineering cost?

We bill time and materials against an initial deposit, generally $2,500 to $3,500 for a new project, and refund anything unused. See what does a structural engineer cost in Oregon?

Talk to us before you pay for plans

Call 541-338-9488 or email info@jbe.us.com, and attach any drawings or sketches you have. We return every new inquiry the same day if possible, and by the next business day at the latest. Monday–Friday, 8:00 a.m.–5:00 p.m. If we can’t get to the phone, leave a message and we’ll call you back.

Call 541-338-9488 Contact us
Back To Top